HR Matters E-Tips
This Week's Tip: Tape Recording Counseling Sessions Q&A
Published by Personnel Policy Service, Inc.
"Your Policy and Compliance Experts Since 1972"
To unsubscribe - see bottom of page
| This Week's Tip: Tape
Recording Counseling Sessions Q&A
Q: An employee wants to tape record a meeting his supervisor has
scheduled to discuss performance problems. Should we allow him to do
this? What if we refuse and he does it anyway?
A: Generally, most employers refuse requests to tape meetings.
You are not required by law to permit tape recordings, and there are
several practical reasons not to allow them.
First, as the employer's representative, the supervisor should control
meeting and not let the employee dictate the terms. Just as the
supervisor decides where and when the meeting takes place, how long it
lasts, and what to discuss, the supervisor also should take charge of
other aspects, including whether it is recorded.
Second, an accurate written account of the session generally serves
your purposes better than a taped one, especially if there are any
emotional outbursts or harsh exchanges. A written account can soothe
over rough spots and provide, if needed, a dispassionate perspective at
a hearing or trial.
Finally, the mere act of taping can create an unnatural and stilted
atmosphere that limits open and constructive dialogue during the
Although you have valid reasons to refuse the employee's request, you
should still try to address the concerns that prompted it. For example,
when you communicate your refusal, ask why he wants to record the
meeting. If he is worried about fairness or honesty, ask for specific
examples of problems and then address these with the supervisor.
Further, as an alternative to taping the session, you could offer to let
review the supervisor's post-session written account and then make
additions to clarify or dispute the supervisor's version. This offer
soften your refusal, increase his comfort level about what will happen
the meeting, and thus help move the process forward.
Of course, the employee may ignore your refusal and record the session
anyway. In that case, you have grounds to discipline the employee for
insubordination. Also, an unauthorized recording may have legal
For example, in some states, like California, Illinois, and Michigan,
is only allowed if all parties to the conversation consent. (In
federal law requires the consent of only one party to the taping.)
Therefore, if you are in a state that requires consent from all parties
your employee makes the recording without the supervisor's permission,
he then also may be subject to criminal action for violating the law.
YOU CAN TRUST PPS
Information provided in HR Matters E-Tips is researched and reviewed
by the HR experts at Personnel Policy Service as well as employment
law attorneys. However, it is not intended as legal advice. Readers are
encouraged to seek appropriate legal or other professional advice.
Interested in using an article from HR Matters E-Tips on your Web site or
in a newsletter?
Please contact Robin Thomas, Managing Editor of Personnel Policy
Service, Inc., to request permission. You can contact her by email at
firstname.lastname@example.org or by
telephone at 1-800-437-3735.
Please note that the information in every issue of HR Matters E-Tips is
the original, copyrighted work of Personnel Policy Service, Inc., and is
protected under U.S. copyright laws. As such, you may not reprint or
publish in any format any article or portion of article from HR Matters E-
Tips without the express permission of Personnel Policy Service, Inc.
Remember, too, we encourage you to pass along any issue of the E-Tips
by forwarding it to friends and colleagues.
HR Matters E-Tips is a f-r-e-e service of Personnel Policy Service, Inc.
To subscribe, go to:
Personnel Policy Service, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
HR Matters is a registered trademark of:
Personnel Policy Service, Inc.
159 St. Matthews Ave., Suite 5, Louisville, KY 40207
Tel: 1-800-437-3735 - Fax: 1-800-755-7011
CONTACT US: email@example.com
FORWARD THIS ISSUE: We invite you to forward HR Matters E-Tips to
a colleague or friend.